I agree. It's not that the open source model means anything bad at all. There are non-free journals that people in a particular field do not respect because they have poor peer review policies or other flaws.
Considering what's at stake, I want to be careful about results from *any* journal with both a brand new model for academic publishing and a study result that changes so much, in a way that so many people will find vindicating.
(no subject)
Date: 2008-02-27 01:20 am (UTC)Considering what's at stake, I want to be careful about results from *any* journal with both a brand new model for academic publishing and a study result that changes so much, in a way that so many people will find vindicating.